Shopify and Square get compared constantly, and most of those comparisons are written for people building online-only stores. That's not you. You run a local business. Maybe a shop with a counter, maybe a restaurant, maybe a service company that's been told it "needs ecommerce."
The right way to compare these two isn't feature checklists. It's understanding what each company actually is, because they came at the same problem from opposite directions, and that origin story still shapes everything about how they work.
Shopify started online and added in-person tools later. Square started at the counter, with that little white card reader, and added a website builder later. Each one is excellent on its home turf and merely adequate on the other's.
What Shopify actually is
Shopify is the heavyweight of small business ecommerce. Online store, inventory, shipping, payments, an enormous app ecosystem, and a point-of-sale system that ties physical retail into the same backend.
Where it shines: anything serious about selling online. Product variants, abandoned cart recovery, shipping integrations, multichannel selling on social platforms and marketplaces, and apps for nearly any workflow you can imagine. If your ambition is real ecommerce volume, Shopify's ceiling is effectively unlimited. Businesses scale from a kitchen table to eight figures without leaving the platform.
Where it costs you: complexity and stacking fees. Shopify plans start around the high twenties per month for the basic tier, but that's rarely the real number. Many of the features you'll want live in third-party apps with their own monthly fees, and unless you use Shopify's own payment processing, you'll pay extra transaction fees on top of card rates. A "cheap" Shopify store commonly ends up at two or three times the base plan once it's actually doing its job.
What Square Online actually is
Square is, first and foremost, a point-of-sale and payments company. The website builder (Square Online, which absorbed Weebly after Square bought it) exists to give Square merchants an online front door that talks to the same catalog, inventory, and payments as the register.
Where it shines: if you already run your counter on Square, the integration is genuinely seamless. Your items sync. Your inventory is one pool. A pickup order placed online deducts from the same stock as a walk-in sale. For restaurants, Square's online ordering connects directly to your kitchen flow without paying third-party marketplace commissions on every order. And you can start with a free website tier and pay mostly through processing fees, which is a very friendly on-ramp for a business watching every dollar.
Where it falls short: the website builder itself is basic. Limited templates, limited design control, limited SEO flexibility. A Square Online site looks like a Square Online site. It's a functional storefront bolted to a great POS, not a marketing asset. If you want your website to actually win customers rather than just serve existing ones, you'll feel the limits quickly.
The real decision: which ecosystem owns your counter?
Here's the thing most comparisons bury. For a local business, the website builder is the tail. The POS is the dog.
- Already on Square at the register? Use Square Online. The integration benefits outweigh almost any feature Shopify has. Running two systems that don't share inventory is a daily tax on your time and a recipe for overselling.
- Already on Shopify POS? Stay in Shopify. Same logic in reverse.
- Starting fresh, mostly in-person sales (cafe, salon retail, food truck, farmers market)? Square. It's simpler, cheaper to start, and built for the counter-first business.
- Starting fresh, with real ambitions to sell online beyond your zip code? Shopify. You'll outgrow Square Online's storefront, and migrating an established store is painful.
A note for restaurants specifically
Online ordering is where this choice gets concrete. Square's restaurant tooling (menus, modifiers, pickup and delivery ordering, kitchen displays) is purpose-built and integrates with the POS your staff already touches all day. Shopify can do restaurant ordering through apps, but it's a retrofit. Unless you have an unusual setup, restaurants comparing these two should lean Square and spend the saved energy on the thing that actually fills tables: your Google Business Profile, your photos, and your reviews. For most local restaurants, the Google listing drives more orders than the website does.
Pricing, honestly
Both companies adjust pricing regularly, so verify before you commit. The broad strokes:
- Square Online: Free tier exists (with Square branding and processing fees). Paid tiers are modest. The real cost is the per-transaction processing, which is competitive and simple. Very low risk to start.
- Shopify: No meaningful free tier, base plans from roughly the high twenties monthly, plus apps, plus themes (decent paid themes commonly run a few hundred dollars one-time), plus extra transaction fees if you bring your own processor.
For a business doing modest online volume, Square is almost always cheaper. At higher volume, the math shifts and Shopify's tooling earns its keep.
Questions to answer before you commit to either
A platform choice is easy to make and annoying to unmake, so spend ten minutes on these first:
- Where will most of my revenue actually happen? In person, online, or by phone? Build around the biggest number, not the most exciting one. Plenty of owners build an online store that does 3 percent of revenue while the counter that does 90 percent runs on a legacy register.
- Who updates the menu or catalog, and how often? Daily-changing menus and frequently rotating inventory punish clunky workflows. Have the person who'll actually do the updates test both editors before you decide.
- What happens at the register? If staff already know Square hardware, switching POS to chase a website feature is usually a net loss. Retraining a team costs more than any subscription.
- What does leaving look like? On either platform, your product data exports reasonably well, but your store design, reviews, and integrations don't. Assume a future migration means a rebuild, and let that push you toward the platform you can grow with rather than the one that's cheapest today.
When a local service business needs neither
Now the part I care about most, because we see this mistake weekly.
If you're an HVAC company, a plumber, a cleaning and restoration outfit, a landscaper, a trucking company, you don't sell products from a catalog. Nobody adds "water heater replacement" to a cart. Your customer journey is: search, click, skim, call. That's it.
Shopify and Square are both built around a catalog-and-checkout model that simply isn't your business. Putting a service company on an ecommerce platform means paying for ecommerce machinery you'll never use while underinvesting in the things that actually convert for services:
- Service and service-area pages. A real page for each thing you do in each area you serve, because that's how local search works.
- Click-to-call everything. Your phone number, huge, on every screen, especially mobile.
- Proof. Reviews, photos of real jobs, licenses, your face. People hire people.
- Speed. Slow mobile sites bleed the after-hours emergency calls that pay the best.
- A booking or quote path for the customers who won't call.
That's a lead generation site, not a store. It's a different discipline, and it's what we build all day for cleaning and restoration companies, landscapers, trucking firms, and other service businesses. One of our clients, Ramar Transportation, ran for over 20 years without a single lead from the internet. The day after their new site went live, the first one arrived. Not because of a shopping cart. Because the site was finally built to be found and to convert.
The one exception: if your service business has a genuine product side (a cleaning company selling supplies, a restaurant selling sauces and merch), you can bolt a simple Square checkout onto a proper lead generation site and get the best of both. The store should serve the site, not the other way around.
The bottom line
- Shopify is the better ecommerce platform, full stop. Pick it if selling online is a core pillar of the business, not a side experiment, and budget for the real cost, not the sticker price.
- Square Online is the better choice for counter-first local businesses, especially anyone already running Square at the register, and especially restaurants. The website is the weakest part of the package, so don't expect it to do your marketing for you.
- Service businesses should usually skip both and invest in a site built for search and phone calls, because that's where your customers actually are.
Whichever way you go, claim and finish your Google Business Profile first. It's free, and for a local business it routinely outperforms whatever platform decision you agonize over.
Want a website built for how local customers actually buy?
We build done-with-you websites live on a call: you talk, we build, you watch your site take shape in real time. First draft in 24 hours, live in 7 days, guaranteed. Over 1,500 small business sites built in the last 90 days, including service companies like airsupporthvac.com and sanosteam.com.
Pricing starts at $500 for a Minimal site, $2,000 plus $200/mo for Standard with SEO and AI-search optimization, $3,500 plus $400/mo for Max with a 24/7 AI receptionist that answers when you're on a job, and from $6,000 for Super Max with a custom back office. Pay-in-4 and Klarna available.
Veteran-owned, Wilmington, NC. Book a call or compare tiers.